Despite advancements in AI, current models are still unreliable for design tasks, making it crucial for Product Managers to maintain strong design sense. Even in AI-native companies or enterprise settings, PMs are increasingly involved in prototyping and designing AI-powered features, meaning they cannot abdicate design responsibility to AI tools alone. This necessitates PMs developing their own design skills to effectively spec, build, and evaluate AI products. This week, commit to reviewing a recent AI feature spec through the lens of its user interface and experience, identifying areas where AI assistance is insufficient.
What happened
The article argues that while AI has advanced, it remains insufficient for handling design tasks, forcing Product Managers to retain and develop their own design sense. Even with AI tools, PMs in both startups and enterprises are actively designing AI prototypes and features, indicating a continued need for human design oversight and capability.
A scenario you might face
Consider a startup building an AI-powered coding assistant. The PM has been relying on AI to generate UI mockups for new features. However, users are complaining about the inconsistent and unintuitive interface. The article suggests the PM's own design sense is lacking and they cannot solely delegate this to AI. Should the PM invest in design training, hire a dedicated UI/UX designer despite budget constraints, or attempt to integrate AI design tools more effectively with human review?
What changes in your practice
Before your next feature design review, identify three key user flows that will be significantly impacted by the AI component and prepare to evaluate them not just for functionality but for their core design principles. Ask your engineering team if they are seeing specific design constraints imposed by the AI's output that should be addressed in the PRD.
Questions for your team
- 01What specific design principles are most critical for AI-powered features where AI output is currently insufficient?
- 02How can we integrate AI's output into a design workflow without compromising user experience and brand consistency?
- 03What are the key indicators that an AI tool is failing at a design task, and what is the PM's recourse?
- 04What is the right balance between AI-assisted design and human design intervention for different product types?